'We still don't have a lander': NASA's former chief expresses concerns about Artemis architecture

"The genius of Apollo was its simplicity."
(L) Former NASA Administrator Jim Bridenstine testifies during a Senate hearing. (Graeme Jennings-Pool/Getty Images). (R) A prototype of SpaceX's Starship at the company's Texas launch facility. (Loren Elliott/Getty Images)
(L) Former NASA Administrator Jim Bridenstine testifies during a Senate hearing. (Graeme Jennings-Pool/Getty Images). (R) A prototype of SpaceX's Starship at the company's Texas launch facility. (Loren Elliott/Getty Images)

NASA wants to send humans back to the Moon by 2028, but it doesn't have a working lander yet. The agency's former administrator, Jim Bridenstine, has raised concerns over this, asking whether the crewed landers selected for the upcoming Artemis program are actually the right vehicles for the job.

Mock-up of the crew cabin of Blue Origin’s Blue Moon Mark 2 lander at NASA's JSC. (Image Source: NASA)
Mock-up of the crew cabin of Blue Origin’s Blue Moon Mark 2 lander at NASA's JSC. (Image Source: NASA)

During his appearance on the This Week in Space podcast on June 12, Bridenstine, who now serves as the CEO of Quantum Space, said, "We still don't have a lander, and without a lander, you can't land on the Moon. It's really that simple, and I worry that over time that's going to come back and bite us." He added that the priority right now should simply be building a working lander as fast as possible. 

Artemis is "extraordinarily complicated," says Bridenstine

The Artemis architecture has many moving parts, which Bridenstine believes could complicate things. During the Apollo missions, the Saturn V rocket carried both the astronauts' capsule and the lunar lander together in a single launch. "The genius of Apollo was its simplicity," Bridenstine said.

These artists’ concepts show SpaceX’s Starship Human Landing System (HLS) on the Moon (Representative Image Source: NASA Image and Video Library | NASA)
These artists’ concepts show SpaceX’s Starship Human Landing System (HLS) on the Moon (Representative Image Source: NASA Image and Video Library | NASA)

On the contrary, Artemis lunar landing missions will require the lander and the Orion spacecraft to take off on separate launch vehicles. Commenting on this, he said, "The architecture is extraordinarily complicated." He added, "They [engineers on Apollo] designed that thing to be as simple as you could possibly make it, and because of that they were able to land on the moon eight years after John F. Kennedy declared that we were doing it."

How close are Starship and Blue Moon to being ready?

As of now, neither SpaceX's Starship nor Blue Origin's Blue Moon has reached orbit. Before they do so, they need to clear safety checks, which include test landings on the Moon without any crew aboard. Making matters even harder, neither lander can complete a Moon landing on its own fuel. This means they need to be topped off in orbit by a series of separate launches acting like fuel trucks, and a NASA OIG report estimated that Starship alone could need at least 15 refueling flights for a single lunar landing mission. Bridenstine also brought up NASA's SLS rocket as a rare counterexample, saying, "The first time SLS launched, it was rated for crew, and it was ready to go to the moon on the first launch. That's hard to do, and yet it did it."

The Artemis III crew poses for an official portrait (from left: Andre Douglas, Luca Parmitano, Randy Bresnik, Frank Rubio).
(Cover Image Source: NASA/Bill Stafford)
The Artemis III crew poses for an official portrait (from left: Andre Douglas, Luca Parmitano, Randy Bresnik, and Frank Rubio). (Image Source: NASA/Bill Stafford)

Artemis III mission design is a telltale sign

Before NASA attempts to land humans on the Moon with Artemis IV, it will test out the mission architecture on Artemis III, which is set for mid-to-late 2027. During that flight, Orion will link up with both landers in orbit around Earth over roughly two weeks. Astronauts will actually get to board Blue Moon during this test, but Starship will only carry a docking adapter rather than a working crew cabin—a sign of the kind of progress SpaceX has made with its lander. This also suggests that Blue Moon could be in the running to serve as the lander for Artemis IV, even though it was Starship that was initially chosen for the job.

More on Starlust

Why do many people still believe Moon landings were faked?

Artemis mission update: NASA tests hardware for refueling spacecraft in low-Earth orbit

MORE STORIES

It had only been a day since the historic tower catch at the end of Flight 15, when Elon Musk shared that Starship V4 is going to be about 40 percent taller than the current version (V3).
1 hour ago
Starship's Flight 15 marked the second time the rocket reached orbit. At 22.5 hours, it was also its longest mission to date.
23 hours ago
Musk said that “Ship 42 brings back a motherlode of data for further improvements to the heat shield," as he inspected the upper stage after a successful catch.
21 hours ago
The rocket lifted off on November 15 at 12:40 pm EST from Florida’s Cape Canaveral Space Force Station but suffered an anomaly just 10 minutes after launch.
1 day ago
SpaceX's increased launch capacity will be absorbed by its own programs rather than made available to commercial customers. In this light, companies like Meridian Space could help reduce dependency on launch services.
1 day ago
SpaceX successfully caught Starship’s upper stage using the launch tower for the first time on the rocket's 15th integrated test flight launched on November 13.
2 days ago
Rocket Lab launched the 100th mission of its Electron rocket with a private Japanese satellite from New Zealand. This also marked the 11th mission for this particular customer.
2 days ago
Starship Flight 15 hasn't really been perfect, with the booster catch being called off. But Ship 42 is still doing well.
2 days ago
The Shuttle program's achievements are being harvested to this day, but the Challenger and Columbia disasters are difficult to forget.
3 days ago
A report says that NASA leadership is discussing new strategies to bring rock samples from Mars and China's Tiawen-3 mission is a major motivation.
3 days ago