✕
Astronomy Constellation Deep Sky Objects Skywatching Instruments Spaceflight Videos
Moon Phases
Home / Galleries

This Oxford philosopher hopes humanity's search for extraterrestrial life "finds nothing"

Astronomy Aug 7, 2026
BY ANKITA GARKOTI
Image of a man meeting an alien. (Cover Image Source: designprojects/Getty Images)
Image of a man meeting an alien. (Cover Image Source: designprojects/Getty Images)
Discovering complex fossils on Mars would be "by far the worst news ever printed on a newspaper cover," says an Oxford philosopher. Here’s why.
5 Photos
1 / 5
“Silence of the night sky is golden"
IMAGE SOURCE: ALICIA FUNDERBURK(R);1280927769(L)/GETTY IMAGES

“Silence of the night sky is golden"

In our search for life beyond our home planet, finding even a small sign that alien life exists would be considered one of the greatest moments in human history. But not everyone shares that excitement. Nick Bostrom, director of the Future of Humanity Institute at the University of Oxford, has argued that he hopes our search for life beyond Earth comes up empty.

In his paper, “Where Are They? Why I Hope the Search for Extraterrestrial Life Finds Nothing,” Bostrom explains the reasoning behind his view. He even wrote that he hopes "our Mars probes will discover nothing," adding that "dead rocks and lifeless sands would lift my spirit." So why would an Oxford philosopher root against one of science's biggest dreams? Read on to find out.

2 / 5
"There exists a Great Filter"
IMAGE SOURCE: GREMLIN/GETTY IMAGES

"There exists a Great Filter"

With around 100 billion stars in our galaxy and countless Earth-like planets among them, intelligent life should, statistically, be everywhere. But Bostrom points out that "humans have, to date, seen no sign of any extraterrestrial intelligent civilization." From this, he concludes that "there exists a Great Filter," which he describes as a probability barrier.

In his paper, he noted, “You start with billions and billions of potential germination points for life, and you end up with a sum total of zero extraterrestrial civilizations that we can observe. The Great Filter must therefore be powerful enough – which is to say, the critical steps must be improbable enough – that even with many billions rolls of the dice, one ends up with nothing: no aliens, no spacecraft, no signals, at least none that we can detect in our neck of the woods.”

3 / 5
Could the filter already be behind us?
IMAGE SOURCE: NZOKA JOHN/GETTY IMAGES

Could the filter already be behind us?

The origin of life itself is a strong sign, since "no instance of abiogenesis has ever been observed" even with many lab attempts to recreate it. Bostrom also noted that it took 1.8 billion years for simple cells to evolve into more complex ones with a nucleus, a transition that, as far as we know, only happened once. 

If that step really is the rare one, it would mean the Great Filter is behind us, and “we are most likely the only such civilization in our galaxy or even in the entire observable universe.”

4 / 5
Or is the real danger still ahead of us?
IMAGE SOURCE: FOTOKITA/GETTY IMAGES

Or is the real danger still ahead of us?

There’s another possibility. It might be that the civilizations that reach the stage of development we have made so far are destroyed by “something,” even before they can spread through the galaxy. Bostrom lists threats like nuclear war and "superintelligent general artificial intelligence with destructive goals" as candidates. 

But for any of these to be the actual Great Filter, it would need to be something that nearly every advanced civilization eventually faces with disastrous consequences almost every time.

5 / 5
But why would finding alien life be bad news?
IMAGE SOURCE: SCIEPRO/SCIENCE PHOTO LIBRARY/GETTY IMAGES

But why would finding alien life be bad news?

He explains that if we found simple life on Mars, "it would show that the Great Filter must exist somewhere after that period in evolution." And if the fossils looked more advanced, "we would have to conclude that the probability is very great that the bulk of the Great Filter is ahead of us." 

The more complex the life we find, the more it means that our hardest test, as humanity, is still ahead. If we find nothing, this would mean the Great Filter sits in our past. Bostrom says this is why he believes "that the silence of the night sky is golden."

MORE GALLERIES

5 breathtaking images of the universe captured by NASA's James Webb Space Telescope 6

5 breathtaking images of the universe captured by NASA's James Webb Space Telescope

Nov 20, 2026
Trump recalls ‘very strange’ UFO sightings by Air Force pilots; Harvard physicist also weighs in 5

Trump recalls ‘very strange’ UFO sightings by Air Force pilots; Harvard physicist also weighs in

Nov 19, 2026
‘Most UFO sightings can be explained’: SETI scientist Seth Shostak offers a scientific perspective on alien claims 5

‘Most UFO sightings can be explained’: SETI scientist Seth Shostak offers a scientific perspective on alien claims

Nov 18, 2026
‘They love to think the government is keeping it all secret’: SETI scientist Seth Shostak on America’s alien obsession 5

‘They love to think the government is keeping it all secret’: SETI scientist Seth Shostak on America’s alien obsession

Nov 16, 2026
‘Why are the aliens so interested in the United States?’ SETI scientist Seth Shostak questions UFO sightings 5

‘Why are the aliens so interested in the United States?’ SETI scientist Seth Shostak questions UFO sightings

Nov 14, 2026
Could microbes live beneath Mars’ surface? A new study raises the question 5

Could microbes live beneath Mars’ surface? A new study raises the question

Nov 12, 2026
How Soviet cosmonaut Alexei Leonov almost became the first human on the Moon 5

How Soviet cosmonaut Alexei Leonov almost became the first human on the Moon

Nov 10, 2026
Could a black hole actually split in two? Physicists say it’s not impossible 5

Could a black hole actually split in two? Physicists say it’s not impossible

Nov 10, 2026
The Soviet Union built its own space shuttle to rival NASA, only for it to end in tragedy 5

The Soviet Union built its own space shuttle to rival NASA, only for it to end in tragedy

Nov 9, 2026
Pilots report a mysterious pill-shaped UFO at 41,000 feet over Ohio, and the case remains unexplained 5

Pilots report a mysterious pill-shaped UFO at 41,000 feet over Ohio, and the case remains unexplained

Nov 7, 2026
President Trump honored with gold plaque at MAX POWER Expo by NASA chief and Artemis crew: See images 5

President Trump honored with gold plaque at MAX POWER Expo by NASA chief and Artemis crew: See images

Nov 7, 2026
Are we alone in the universe? 5 discoveries that made alien life seem possible 6

Are we alone in the universe? 5 discoveries that made alien life seem possible

Nov 6, 2026
How a 1947 UFO sighting near Mt. Rainier popularized the term “flying saucer” 5

How a 1947 UFO sighting near Mt. Rainier popularized the term “flying saucer”

Nov 5, 2026
NASA-funded study reveals a Sahara meteorite is one of the oldest pieces of Mars ever found 5

NASA-funded study reveals a Sahara meteorite is one of the oldest pieces of Mars ever found

Nov 5, 2026
What does the Moon smell like? Here’s how Apollo astronauts described it 5

What does the Moon smell like? Here’s how Apollo astronauts described it

Nov 5, 2026
This mysterious radio source has baffled astronomers for more than 20 years: Here’s why 5

This mysterious radio source has baffled astronomers for more than 20 years: Here’s why

Nov 4, 2026
Goodbye, 3I/ATLAS: What scientists learned from this mysterious interstellar comet’s flyby 6

Goodbye, 3I/ATLAS: What scientists learned from this mysterious interstellar comet’s flyby

Nov 2, 2026
Does dark energy really exist? Some physicists are betting it doesn’t 5

Does dark energy really exist? Some physicists are betting it doesn’t

Nov 1, 2026
NASA’s Webb telescope reveals thousands of galaxies in its first deep field image 5

NASA’s Webb telescope reveals thousands of galaxies in its first deep field image

Oct 30, 2026
Project Sign: The U.S. Air Force's first UFO investigation that left 20 percent of cases a mystery 5

Project Sign: The U.S. Air Force's first UFO investigation that left 20 percent of cases a mystery

Oct 30, 2026
Starlust.org is part of the Scale Content Inc. publishing group.

Google Source

About Us
Editorial Guidelines
Privacy Policy
Cookie Policy
Terms of Use
Contact Us
Link to Facebook
Link to Instagram

© Scale Content Inc. 1178 Broadway, 3rd Floor #3469, New York, NY 10001, United States