We may have overlooked one of the biggest clues to alien life, says expert

What if technosignatures and biosignatures are not the only ways intelligent alien life can make itself apparent?
Alien walking on an exoplanet with ancient ruins. (Representative Cover Image Source: Getty Images/gremlin)
Alien walking on an exoplanet with ancient ruins. (Representative Cover Image Source: Getty Images/gremlin)

For years, scientists across the world have searched for the signs of life beyond our home planet in two main ways. They have either looked for signs of biology on other worlds, known as biosignatures, or clues to advanced alien technology, known as technosignatures. But now, researchers think that we may be overlooking something important. If these are the only signs we're looking for, we may be missing intelligent life that's more advanced than microbes but doesn't have the kind of technology we'd expect.

Meeting an alien and an astronaut on a mysterious planet in a distant deep space.
Image of a human meeting an alien on a mysterious planet in a distant deep space. (Representative Image Source: designprojects/Getty Images)

Astrobiologist Julia DeMarines, who has worked on both biosignature and technosignature research, is now working on a new area of study called noosemiotics. The term comes from "nous," which is the ancient Greek concept for the theory of mind. This is built around an idea that anything shaped by a conscious mind carries a signature of intelligence, whether or not it involves circuitry. "We want to figure out if we can detect signatures of intelligence that occur before the invention of radio communication," DeMarines told Space.com. "We're looking at the ways that mind can be imprinted on matter."

3D rendered image of an astronaut meeting an alien on a planet such as Mars (Representative Image Source: Getty | NiseriN)
3D rendered image of an astronaut meeting an alien on a planet such as Mars (Image Source: Getty/NiseriN)

The idea actually comes from an assignment she took on while working for a company applying Assembly Theory, a chemistry framework built by scientists Sara Walker and Lee Cronin, to look for complexity thresholds in online data and AI systems. As a thought exercise, DeMarines applied that thinking to 'bread as a technosignature.’ "I know how that sounds," she said, laughing. "I get weird looks when I tell people about it!" DeMarines explained, “Bread doesn't just pop out of a molecular cloud, it requires technology, it requires history, it requires intelligence." In other words, the history of bread reflects the history of human intelligence. “Say that you have samples of bread at different human and hominin archaeological sites throughout time, dating back 14,000 years—the bread would be a signature of intelligence changing over time as the type of bread, its ingredients, and how it is made also change,” she added.

What does this mean for the search for aliens?

The implications reach well beyond archaeology. Long before humans invented radio, farming was already changing the planet's atmosphere. Roughly three-quarters of all human-generated nitrogen emissions were released before industrialization even began, largely from farming practices like fertilizer use and microbes in the soil. That disruption to Earth's nitrogen cycle started thousands of years ago.

Aliens walking in remote landscape. 3D generated image.
Aliens walking in a remote landscape. 3D generated image. (Representative Image Source: gremlin/Getty Images)

Humans have only been broadcasting radio signals for about 100 years, and that's usually treated as the moment Earth became "visible" to the rest of the universe as an intelligent civilization. But if disruptions to the nitrogen cycle are also detectable from afar, then alien observers watching Earth could, in theory, have been privy to the existence of intelligent life on Earth for longer than we expected, simply by noticing the chemical fingerprint agriculture leaves behind.

Alien mothership near Earth. (Image Source: 3000ad/Getty Images)
Alien ship near Earth. (Representative Image Source: 3000ad/Getty Images)

The framework also makes room for intelligence that never becomes technological, like dolphins, which show remarkable social sophistication but lack the physical means to build tools. DeMarines hasn't worked out how to detect noosignatures on other worlds yet. For now, she's focused on defining the metrics and thresholds. Her research is detailed in a paper published on the open-source repository arXiv. If this holds up, it could change how we look for extraterrestrial life. So, instead of looking for only radio signals, we can start looking for signs that hint at intelligent life, such as disrupted atmospheric chemistry that even non-technological civilizations might trigger. It also hints that intelligent life might be more common than we think, but simply overlooked because we've been searching for the wrong kind of evidence all along.

More on Starlust

Astronomer reveals one of the biggest misconceptions about alien life

Size matters: A planet needs to be at least as big as Mars for alien life to survive on it

MORE STORIES

This new U.S. air show and exposition is expected to eventually draw more than half a million visitors a year to Kennedy Space Center in Florida.
1 day ago
This past week, several new exoplanets were added to NASA's archives, while in spaceflight, several new builds progressed. Here's a wrap-up of space-related news that flew beneath the radar.
2 days ago
Dimorphos, which orbits Didymos, was struck by NASA's DART spacecraft in 2022, altering its orbit. Now, Hera has given us a close-up view of the binary asteroid system.
2 days ago
The ESA's ExoMars Trace Gas Orbiter (TGO) has found magmatic gas above a volcano on Mars. This could have huge implications for the search of life on the planet.
2 days ago
The study asserts that it is very unlikely that comets brought ingredients of life to Earth because most of them would not have survived impacts with our planet.
4 days ago
37 dwarf galaxies lying within 22 million light-years of Earth have between just 4% and 25% of the oxygen that their stars are known to have produced. Scientists are not sure where the rest went.
4 days ago
A new study claims that the VVV CL001 cluster is around 13.4 billion years old, which could make it the oldest star cluster in the Milky Way.
4 days ago
The Universe didn't see light travel freely until 380,000 years after the Big Bang. Then it was plunged into a long period of darkness again. Oliver Zier from the Center for Astrophysics | Harvard & Smithsonian explains what the cosmic dark ages might have felt like, and more in a conversation with Starlust.
5 days ago
This rose-colored meteorite named Teghaza 001 is said to be more than 4 billion years old and holds invaluable clues about the young red planet.
7 days ago
Get insights into the development of a new space station, rising amounts of space debris, and more in this week's space recap.
Oct 30, 2026