Did comets bring building blocks of life to Earth? New study challenges long-standing theory

The study asserts that it is very unlikely that comets brought ingredients of life to Earth because most of them would not have survived impacts with our planet.
An image of the comet Tempel 1 captured by NASA's Deep Impact's impactor spacecraft on July 4, 2005. (Cover Image Source: NASA/JPL-Caltech/UMD)
An image of the comet Tempel 1 captured by NASA's Deep Impact's impactor spacecraft on July 4, 2005. (Cover Image Source: NASA/JPL-Caltech/UMD)

A new study published in Scientific Reports has challenged the long-standing theory that the building blocks of life on Earth were delivered by comets. A team of researchers led by the University of Cambridge has proposed that these prebiotic molecules would have been destroyed upon cometary impact, and if any of the molecules luckily survived, they wouldn’t have been concentrated enough to kickstart life.

View of planet Earth, Moon and a comet from space. Elements of this image furnished by NASA. (Image Source: Getty Photos | buradaki)

The researchers used computer simulations to recreate a younger Earth and the cometary bombardments it faced, running 100,000 simulations of Earth’s early cometary history. During the early intense bombardment phase, over 4 billion years ago, our planet was pummeled by more than 100,000 comets larger than 100 meters (328 feet). However, even this heavy bombardment wasn’t enough because the comets were traveling too fast at unfavorable angles and were almost certainly vaporized upon impact, the study says. There are numerous studies that say comets may have been a delivery vehicle for water as well as prebiotic molecules, but the theories are still disputed.

A picture of the Halley's Comet. (Image Source: NASA-JPL/Caltech)

“Historically, scientists thought that comets were important for the origin of life on Earth, because they carried carbon- and nitrogen-bearing molecules, so these giant space snowballs were almost like a ‘get out of jail free card’ that brought all the molecules a planet would need to seed life,” Dr. Richard Anslow from Cambridge’s Institute of Astronomy and lead author of the study said in a statement. “It’s kind of a romantic idea, but our results suggest it’s highly unlikely.” In the simulations, there were zero successful impacts in 54 percent of the scenarios, whereas there was at least one in the remaining 46 percent. Anslow and his team had published a study in 2023 showing that comets could ‘bounce’ from one world to another and successfully deliver organic molecules in exoplanet systems where planets orbit closely, but the latest study found that this orbital architecture makes such an event extremely rare in our own Solar System.

An image of the Comet Hartley 2 captured by NASA's EPOXI mission. (Image Source: NASA/JPL-Caltech/UMD)

In their simulation, the scientists focused on hydrogen cyanide (HCN), which is a ‘key feedstock molecule’ that can synthesize many of the building blocks of life, including lipids, sugars, nucleobases, and nucleotides in high concentrations. An important condition for the fragile HCN molecules to survive is that the comets don’t impact Earth at a steep angle and their speed is not too high. Another major condition is that the HCN—if it survives the destructive impact—must stay concentrated for a long time, and prebiotic chemistry must begin shortly after the crash.

Artist concept of the early Earth's surface. (Image Source: NASA Astrobiology Institute)

“It would really have to be a one-in-a-million occurrence, because not only would you need an impact at just the right speed and just the right angle, you would also need everything to happen after that point, in terms of the concentration and the speed at which the chemical origins of life got going,” Anslow said. “We can’t rule out for certain that it happened that way. But it seems to be a really rare occurrence – at best, a one-off fluke.”

A twinkling comet in a blue starry sky. (Representative Image Source: Getty Photos | ClaudioVentrella)

If the comets didn't bring these molecules, the study authors said that one possible explanation could be their delivery by asteroids, which were impacting Earth much more frequently than comets. It's also possible that the chemistry of life may have started on our planet spontaneously without any outside help. Additionally, the study presented another fascinating theory which says the cometary impacts may have been more productive on Mars. The planet has weaker gravity and probably had a thinner atmosphere, which would have kept a large portion of the comet intact even after impact. But the researchers stressed that this may not have happened at all. According to Anslow, the "more likely, alternative is that it didn’t happen on either planet."

More on Starlust

Veiled in dust for billions of years, this ancient star cluster could be the oldest in the Milky Way

Vera C. Rubin Observatory may have discovered one of the largest dwarf planets hidden beyond Pluto

MORE STORIES

In an exclusive interview with Starlust.org, Dr. Seth Shostak of the SETI Institute shared his views on finding alien life and on the recently declassified UFO files.
11 hours ago
Earth's newly captured mini-moon measures about 3 feet (1 meter) wide and it will be around 353,000 miles from our planet at its closest distance.
1 day ago
This new U.S. air show and exposition is expected to eventually draw more than half a million visitors a year to Kennedy Space Center in Florida.
3 days ago
This past week, several new exoplanets were added to NASA's archives, while in spaceflight, several new builds progressed. Here's a wrap-up of space-related news that flew beneath the radar.
4 days ago
Dimorphos, which orbits Didymos, was struck by NASA's DART spacecraft in 2022, altering its orbit. Now, Hera has given us a close-up view of the binary asteroid system.
4 days ago
The ESA's ExoMars Trace Gas Orbiter (TGO) has found magmatic gas above a volcano on Mars. This could have huge implications for the search of life on the planet.
4 days ago
37 dwarf galaxies lying within 22 million light-years of Earth have between just 4% and 25% of the oxygen that their stars are known to have produced. Scientists are not sure where the rest went.
6 days ago
A new study claims that the VVV CL001 cluster is around 13.4 billion years old, which could make it the oldest star cluster in the Milky Way.
6 days ago
The Universe didn't see light travel freely until 380,000 years after the Big Bang. Then it was plunged into a long period of darkness again. Oliver Zier from the Center for Astrophysics | Harvard & Smithsonian explains what the cosmic dark ages might have felt like, and more in a conversation with Starlust.
7 days ago
This rose-colored meteorite named Teghaza 001 is said to be more than 4 billion years old and holds invaluable clues about the young red planet.
Nov 1, 2026