Apollo Moon samples suggest meteorites did not exactly fill Earth's oceans

Earlier research held that meteorite impacts from the solar system's early days were a major source of Earth's water.
Meteor impacting Earth, computer artwork. (Representative Cover Image Credit: Andrzej Wojcicki/Getty Images)
Meteor impacting Earth, computer artwork. (Representative Cover Image Credit: Andrzej Wojcicki/Getty Images)

Studies so far suggested that a major source of water on Earth may have been meteorites that slammed into our planet in the early days of the solar system. A new NASA study published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences that analyzed Apollo samples, however, suggests otherwise. Led by Tony Gargano, a postdoctoral fellow at NASA's Johnson Space Center and the Lunar and Planetary Institute, the study claims that water delivered by meteorite impacts from 4 billion years ago only accounts for a small fraction of Earth's water content.

A close-up view of a portion of a
A close-up view of a portion of a "relatively fresh" crater, looking southeast, as photographed during the third Apollo 15 lunar surface moonwalk. (Image Source: NASA; Image Resized by Starlust Staff)

While the Earth's dynamic crust and fluctuating weather make it difficult to trace the impacts that it experienced billions of years ago, the Moon preserves its own history quite well, thus acting like an archive for the Earth-Moon system as a whole. That being said, accessing said archive is no cakewalk. Traditional methods of regolith analysis focus on "metal-loving elements," which run the risk of getting corrupted by repeated impacts on the Moon, thus making it hard to detect what the meteorites contained originally.

A close-up of Apollo 17 lunar core sample 73001 being taken out of its drive tube for the first time since it was collected by Apollo astronauts in December 1972 at NASA’s Johnson Space Center in Houston (Image Source: NASA | Robert Markowitz)
A close-up of Apollo 17 lunar core sample 73001 being taken out of its drive tube for the first time since it was collected by Apollo astronauts in December 1972 at NASA’s Johnson Space Center in Houston (Image Source: NASA/Robert Markowitz)

To circumvent this problem, the researchers turned to triple oxygen isotopes, which are extremely accurate "fingerprints," because of the ability of oxygen—the dominant element by mass in rocks—to remain unaltered by external impacts. As a result, they offer a much clearer picture of what the meteorites that hit the Earth-Moon system were composed of. From the measurement of these oxygen isotopes, it was found that a minimum of ~1% by mass of the dusty lunar surface has material brought by meteorites with high carbon content, which were partially vaporized upon impact with the surface of the Moon. Knowing these properties allowed the research team to figure out how much water these meteorites had within them. 

3d rendered image of planet Earth with the Moon (Representative Cover Image Source: Getty | mikiell)
3d rendered image of planet Earth with the Moon (Representative Image Source: Getty/mikiell)

"The lunar regolith is one of the rare places we can still interpret a time-integrated record of what was hitting Earth’s neighborhood for billions of years," explained Gargano, per a NASA press release. "The oxygen-isotope fingerprint lets us pull an impactor signal out of a mixture that’s been melted, vaporized, and reworked countless times." Upon being scaled up by about 20 times to factor in the higher rate of impacts on Earth, the model showed that the water from the meteorites accounted for a very small part of the water found in Earth's oceans. "Our results don’t say meteorites delivered no water," said Justin Simon, study co-author and planetary scientist at NASA Johnson's Astromaterials Research and Exploration Science Division. "They say the Moon’s long-term record makes it very hard for late meteorite delivery to be the dominant source of Earth’s oceans."

Artist’s concept of SpaceX Starship human landing system. (Representative Image Source: SpaceX)
Artist’s concept of SpaceX Starship human landing system on the Moon. (Representative Image Source: SpaceX)

While the water delivered by meteorites is rather small in the context of Earth, it is far from insignificant for the Moon, whose accessible water content is found in small, permanently shadowed regions at the poles. These poles are two of the coldest places not just on the Moon but in the entire solar system. They will open up new doors in terms of resources for lunar exploration once the Artemis III mission gets humans back on the Moon's surface. After all, while the Apollo samples brought to Earth over 50 years ago continue to be valuable, they represent only a small portion of the lunar soil.

More on Starlust

Lunar landers could accidentally ruin the hunt for biological building blocks on the Moon

NASA's Artemis missions timeline: What happens after Artemis II?

MORE STORIES

It was business as usual for the private aerospace industry this week. Meanwhile, humanity took a step closer to understanding the mysteries of the dark universe.
3 days ago
“These are far more than beautiful pictures; today marks a scientific milestone in our study of the cosmos.”
2 days ago
LISA may help detect exoplanets around binary white dwarfs, something that has never been done before.
4 days ago
In an exclusive interview with Starlust.org, Dr. Seth Shostak of the SETI Institute shared his views on finding alien life and on the recently declassified UFO files.
6 days ago
Earth's newly captured mini-moon measures about 3 feet (1 meter) wide and it will be around 353,000 miles from our planet at its closest distance.
2 days ago
This new U.S. air show and exposition is expected to eventually draw more than half a million visitors a year to Kennedy Space Center in Florida.
Nov 7, 2026
This past week, several new exoplanets were added to NASA's archives, while in spaceflight, several new builds progressed. Here's a wrap-up of space-related news that flew beneath the radar.
Nov 6, 2026
Dimorphos, which orbits Didymos, was struck by NASA's DART spacecraft in 2022, altering its orbit. Now, Hera has given us a close-up view of the binary asteroid system.
Nov 6, 2026
The ESA's ExoMars Trace Gas Orbiter (TGO) has found magmatic gas above a volcano on Mars. This could have huge implications for the search of life on the planet.
Nov 6, 2026
The study asserts that it is very unlikely that comets brought ingredients of life to Earth because most of them would not have survived impacts with our planet.
Nov 4, 2026